418 S SCHAEFER Street

418 S Schaefer St, Appleton, WI 54915 For Sale

👉 MLS: 50330550

🛏🛏🛏 3 Bed

🛁🚽1.5 Bath

🚗🚗 2 Car Garage

☀️ 15x15 - 4 Seasons Room

🔥Large Lower Family Room with Wood Burning Fireplace

View More Info & Photos Below! A 360 Virtual Tour is near the bottom of this page!

Blue and stone ranch home for sale at 418 S Schaefer St, Appleton, WI

Call your Realtor to set up a showing or call me at (920) 209-1079 to set up your showing!

🏡 Classic Stone & Cedar Ranch — Between Two Parks, Improved by Every Owner Since 2014

Some homes ask you to picture what they could be. This one just asks when you'd like to move in.

Set on a quiet stretch of Appleton's south side, this 3-bedroom ranch pairs the warmth of 1960s craftsmanship — stone accents, cedar shake, a wood-wrapped four-season room — with something rarer: a track record. Multiple owners have steadily invested in this home for over a decade, from a full remodel down to the fences, doors, and paint.

Wood-paneled four-season room with sliding glass doors off the primary bedroom at 418 S Schaefer St, Appleton, WI

☀️ A Four-Season Room That Steals the Show

Just off the main bedroom, the 15x15 four-season room is wrapped in windows and warm wood paneling — sunny enough for morning coffee in January, breezy enough for game night in July — all overlooking the fully fenced backyard and patio.

🛏️ Easy One-Level Living

All three bedrooms and the full bath sit on the main floor, along with an 18x13 living room anchored by a big picture window and a 14x12 eat-in kitchen. The stainless Frigidaire refrigerator (2023) and dishwasher (2025) stay, along with the oven/range and microwave.

Living room with large picture window and hardwood floors at 418 S Schaefer St, Appleton, WI

🎬 A Lower Level Built for Spreading Out

Downstairs, the 42-foot family room with its stone fireplace is the stuff of movie marathons, game days, and hobby corners — plus a convenient half bath, laundry, and plenty of storage. A radon mitigation system and sump pump are already in place for extra peace of mind.

Finished basement family room with stone fireplace at 418 S Schaefer St, Appleton, WI

Stone fireplace in the lower-level family room at 418 S Schaefer St, Appleton, WI

🔧 A Decade-Plus of Improvements, Owner by Owner

The 2014–15 remodel (per prior owners):

✅ Kitchen and bathrooms remodeled
✅ New roof
✅ Basement finished

Prior ownership, per the seller's records:

✅ Replacement windows
✅ New water heater (2019)
✅ New garage door and back storm/screen door
✅ Exterior of house and garage painted
✅ Underground downspouts (front and back) routing rainwater away from the foundation
✅ New landscape curbing, kitchen sink, and blinds

Most recent ownership:

✅ New backyard wood fence + driveway chain-link fence with double gate — Fall 2025
✅ Vendor-certified kick-in-proof security back door — Fall 2025
✅ New side garage access door with security motion light — Fall 2025
✅ Sewer line section replaced — an aging galvanized section swapped for modern PVC (Summer 2026)
✅ Basement crack sealed (Summer 2026)
✅ Fresh interior paint in nearly every room — 2024–2025
✅ Frigidaire stainless dishwasher (2025) and refrigerator (2023)
✅ Retextured basement hallway and bath — 2024

🌳 Out Back & Around Town

The fenced yard, patio, and 2-car detached garage handle everything from summer cookouts to snowblower season. And the location splits the difference between two of the south side's favorite green spaces: Schaefer Park a few blocks one way, and Telulah Park — with its trails and the Lower Telulah kayak launch on the Fox River — the other. The shops and restaurants along E College Ave are right up the street, with downtown Appleton just minutes beyond.